London Office 33 James’ Street
London
SW1Y 4JS

+44 (0) 20 7495 1234

Manchester Office 10 Mount Street
Manchester
M2 5NT

+44 (0) 161 839 0064

Our News

Our expert in-house capability provides accurate, up-to-date and incisive research to deliver swift, precise outcomes. Targeted individuals are engaged with care and professionalism and the client opportunity presented in a clear and well-prepared format.

Our News

Our expert in-house capability provides accurate, up-to-date and incisive research to deliver swift, precise outcomes. Targeted individuals are engaged with care and professionalism and the client opportunity presented in a clear and well-prepared format.

The reign is over: Monarch’s collapse

One week on from the announcement that Monarch Airlines had run out of runway and was entering administration, we thought we’d take a look back at the company’s spectacular take-off, how it fell from grace and what it means for the aviation industry and the future of low-cost carriers – and their staff.

The Heyday
Having set up an Italian tourism company way back in the early 20th century, the Mantegazza family decided to invest in a new airline in 1968 to offer British holidaymakers access to the exoticism of Europe, without the premium price tag. Launching with just two aircraft at London Luton Airport, Monarch soon became the king of foreign package holidays, treating Brits to the sights and sounds of continental destinations throughout the 1970s and 80s.

Increased Competition
The 1980s brought with it a growing public desire for independent travel – people wanted to mix and match their own flights and hotels, rather than settle for pre-assigned options. To satisfy this need, Monarch released its first scheduled flights to Menorca in 1985 – a move that saw it become a direct competitor of other flight-only short-haul carriers. And with the orange glow of easyJet descending on Luton in the mid-90s, the low-cost airline industry boomed.

The focus moved away from customer service and towards cheaper fares, and as the years went on and the competition intensified, Monarch began to struggle. With its traditional business model and persistent legacy issues, it simply couldn’t keep up with more innovative providers, such as Ryanair, Norwegian Air, Wizz Air and Jet2. There was – and continues to be – an extremely congested market on the routes that Monarch flew on.

Political Peril
The political landscape during the company’s last five years of trading was a particular blow to its operations. Terrorist attacks in Egypt, Turkey and Tunisia – some of Monarch’s popular destinations – put a lot of pressure on the flying programme to divert activity to Iberia, which in turn further increased the commercial pressure on the business. The migrant crisis in southern Europe was also detrimental, as was the UK’s vote to leave the EU, which led to the weakened pound.

All of this, combined with the fierce competition from other carriers, created the perfect storm. Despite the hefty injections of cash administered by the Mantegazza family and Greybull Capital, which bought the company in 2014, Monarch’s demise couldn’t be reversed and on 2 October, the company went bankrupt and plans were put in place to repatriate its 110,000 currently overseas passengers.

What now?
Over the past week, Monarch’s collapse together with Ryanair’s flight cancellations has sent ripples through the aviation industry, with Skyscanner reporting that average prices for last-minute European flights have gone up by a quarter.

Meanwhile, to their credit, other carriers have stepped up to offer employment opportunities to some of the 1,800 people made redundant – mostly pilots and cabin crew. All we can hope is that this is extended to the rest of Monarch’s team and they find new roles quickly.

Monarch’s collapse serves as a reminder to the other airlines around the world – to have a clear proposition, make sure schedules are on point, manage their cost base effectively and, importantly, keep innovating and be open to collaboration. It will also be imperative that they look after their people properly if they’re to retain top talent and safeguard their future.

If you work in the aviation industry and want to have a confidential conversation about executive hiring or market conditions, give Nick a call on 07894 586429, or send him an email.

Barry and Clare are a dream team on a mission. They are connected, personable and full of integrity. Barry has managed to fulfil roles that others have failed to recruit and with A-class candidates.

Throw a hard mandate at them and see them deliver.

Jesper With-Fogstrup

” Mandy worked with me as a retained advisor on a board level assignment to recruit an HR Director and a Governance Director. I found the process deployed to be very efficient and Mandy demonstrated excellent knowledge of the sector and ultimately assisted me in securing talented appointments. Mandy’s approach is very thorough and professional, but importantly she also commits to making each element of the task run smoothly and supports the client at all times.”

Marc Bell, Ex CEO of Benenden Healthcare

The EMI Practice at Howgate Sable really took the time to understand our situation and find exceptional candidates who could fulfil challenging international leadership assignments for a truly global company with a history that spans well over 200 years.

It was a first class experience and positive outcome on many levels.

 

Barry McDonnell – Director of Manufacturing at De La Rue International

I have worked with the Howgate Sable team on several occasions whilst hiring mission-critical executives. Partnership is the byword for this organisation – they act as an extension of my team and work hard to support me not only in the technical solution, but in the sense of a deep understanding of my specific requirements. Delivery is the key measure of our talent partners and Howgate Sable have always achieved what was asked of them.

Jesper Berg – SVP HR, ABB

I was headhunted by Howgate Sable for the CEO appointment at Welspun UK (Christy) Limited, a new product sector for me and one I would not have naturally considered.  It turned out to be the best career move I have ever made.  Since taking the role I have worked closely with Barry and his team to build a high-performance team, and this has been achieved through his taking the time to understand our industry sector and our company culture intimately.  I cannot recommend Howgate Sable highly enough for anyone wishing to make a career move or build a team.

Leigh Taylor – CEO, Welspun UK (Christy)

Having worked with Howgate Sable as a client and as a candidate I can confidently say their ability to deliver on complex searches is second to none. They not only have a detailed knowledge of the marketplace but also understand the importance of cultural fit. 

Bridget Lea – O2

I was particularly impressed with Howgate Sable’s knowledge and network in the aviation sector, the quality of the candidates provided at shortlist and the availability of Nick and the team to provide us with advice and guidance on candidates when required. Nick was particularly effective in understanding our needs as a Company and being flexible in adapting requirements and plans.

Paul Hutchings – Thomas Cook Group Airlines

I have recently worked with Nick from Howgate Sable to recruit a new Head of Aircraft Operations for Thomson Airways. I was particularly impressed by the wide-reaching search undertaken and the quality of the candidates put forward. The skills match to the brief was excellent and I am delighted with the individual we selected.

Dawn Wilson – Thomson Airways

From their initial call to me the Aviation practice team at Howgate Sable demonstrated a significant difference. Straightforward and to the point, the extent of their network and deep insight into the industry was immediately evident. The added value I have received as a candidate is tangible. An almost instant rapport quickly developed into a focused business relationship which is open, honest, respectful and above all trustworthy.

Carl Gissing